Misremembering Weimar

hyperinflationHyperinflation, the Great Depression, and German Collective Economic Memory

Lukas Haffert*, Nils Redeker**, and Tobias Rommel***
*University of Zurich, **Jacques Delors Institute Berlin, and ***Technical University of Munich

The economic worldview of German elites and the German public is often described as being shaped by the trauma of Weimar era hyperinflation. This raises the question why this hyperinflation episode plays such an outsized role in the German economic imagination. We argue that this is because many Germans do not distinguish between hyperinflation and the Great Depression but see them as two dimensions of the same crisis. They conceive of Weimar economic history as being characterized by one big crisis, encompassing both rapidly rising prices and mass unemployment. Using original survey data, we demonstrate that about half of all Germans think of the Great Depression as a period of high inflation, whereas less than 5% know that it was in fact a period of deflation. More educated and politically interested Germans are more likely to commit this fallacy. This confusion is unique to Germany, as a comparison with a Dutch survey shows.

Please find our working paper here. You can also find a short discussion of our findings and what that means for Christine Lagarde, the ECB’s new president, in our policy paper, published with the Jacques Delors Institute, Berlin (in English or German).

The results of our study were also covered online by Die Zeit and Handelsblatt, in German, and by Bloomberg and The Spectator, in English. The German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung has also published a piece in their printed edition.